The slap heard around the world

March 31, 2022

by Ravi Raman

This week I’ve been thinking about the thing everyone has been talking about, the slap heard around the world, Will Smith’s altercation with Chris Rock at The Oscar’s a few days ago.

I love both of these performers. They are true artists and strike me not only as talented but deeply kind and mature. Perhaps that is what is striking a nerve in me about this matter, to see behavior that is so at odds with my mental image of a person.

What should we make of this spectacle?

There are no shortage of hot takes on the matter. Some siding with Will’s “chivalry” in defending his wife’s honor against a petty insult hurled from a stage. Others (and seemingly most based on what I’ve been reading) are appalled that someone of Will’s stature would stoop to violence as a response to a joke, even if the joke is interpreted as an insult. To make things clear, I’m firmly in the camp that violence is never a valid response to life’s challenges, except in extreme cases of self-defense.

However, there is something nobody seems to be talking about that any leader (or peacemaker) must understand. What Will did was innocent. This doesn’t mean there should be no repercussions for his actions, but it does mean that the mechanism that drove his behavior is innocently operating behind the scenes for all of us. Without proper understanding, anyone’s mind will take them for a ride, and a very unpleasant one at that.

What Will did was innocently respond to an insecure thought. That’s right, he had a thought, and without self-awareness, responded to it in a way that made sense to him at the moment. It probably didn’t appear that way for Will, he probably was responding to what he saw as a real threat. However, the only threat was created in his mind.

This is the natural functioning of the human mind for all of us…and it’s innocent by design. Thought is so captivating that it appears real, and provokes reactions. We didn’t create this design, but we should learn how to work with it gracefully if we aspire to work well and be well in the world.

Said another way, we are living in a psychological experience, not an experience of circumstances. The mind (and whatever powers the mind) has ultimate control over what we do. When the mind is calm and settled and we have present-moment awareness, even the most heinous thought causes no trouble, passing through us like a wave rolling past a ship in the ocean. However, when we are completely lost in thought, even the most innocent notion can provoke a horrifying reaction.

The implication is this: any of us with the same quality of thoughts and limited self-awareness that Will experienced at that exact moment, would behave just as he did in this scenario.

Through the ages, wisdom traditions have warned against allowing the torrent of thought to drive insecure behavior. The ancients have also taught that with enough presence of mind (self-awareness, mindfulness, and patience) we can break free of such reactivity.

I think this is the real lesson from what we saw at The Oscars. It’s not the “good vs bad” hot takes on the matter. It’s the innocence in which people – even people we love and our very selves – can get caught in something as subtle as an insecure thought, with disastrous consequences.

Let this serve as a warning, to pay more care to mental well-being and the well-being of those we lead and love. Let’s bring more understanding and calm to our days. Not all thoughts require a reaction, but they do require our presence and peace of mind.

Further reading 📚

How to make your work more joyful and less miserable today 

You know the feeling, sleeping walking your way from meeting to meeting. Getting lost in your phone instead of working on that document. Retyping your to-do's instead of actually doing them. The problem is rampant.  While this is clearly an issue for owners and...

Quitting Twitter and getting on with my life

I quit Twitter the other day. It has nothing (really!) to do with Elon and everything to do with how social technology seems designed to fracture, divide and capture attention at the cost of well-being and personal (and group) performance. Moderation was not working...

What I’ve learned this year (2022 edition)

John Dewey, an education reformer and philosopher, is well-known for his understanding that learning doesn't come from experience. It comes from reflecting on experience. Being December as I write this, there is a certain nostalgia in the air as the year comes to a...

It’s time to step off the time management treadmill from hell

There once lived a King in a faraway land. A tyrant who was ruthless though successful in the eyes of the world. Commerce flourished even if heads rolled under his heavy-handed reign. Whatever he wanted was had at any price. Eventually the King was challenged to a...

Bad news and the power of suspending judgment

Michael slipped on a patch of ice getting into a friends car and fell. A self-proclaimed "klutz," taking a tumble wasn't out of the ordinary. This time, embarrassment wasn't the problem. A lingering pain in his wrist meant something serious was going on. An MRI would...